ACLU, Karuk Tribe and FOR File Suit Over Censorship of Klamath Dams Ad! 

by Dan Bacher
Feb 20th, 2008

The ACLU, Karuk Tribe and Friends of the River are standing up for freedom of speech in their campaign to remove four environmentally destructive dams on the Klamath River , owned by Warren Buffett-owned subsidiary Berkshire Hathaway.

The ACLU of Oregon this morning filed a lawsuit against Tri-County Metropolitan Transportation District of Oregon (TriMet), alleging the public bus company has violated federal and state constitutional free speech protections in its rejection of an advertisement it deems “political.” The lawsuit was filed in Multnomah County Circuit Court, on behalf of the Karuk Tribe of California and Friends of the River Foundation, who had sought to place an ad on TriMet buses regarding the damage done to salmon runs for decades by electricity-generating dams, owned by Portland-based Pacific Power, on the Klamath River .

TriMet’s "Advertising Standards Committee" rejected the proposed ad on the grounds that it did not constitute an “advertisement” and that the public transit agency did not want its buses or property “to become a public forum for the dissemination, debate, and/or discussion of public issues.” The ACLU appealed the committee’s decision to TriMet’s general manager, who in a letter dated Jan. 18, 2008 , upheld the rejection.

The Tribe and FOR consider the refusal of TriMet to run the ad to be discriminatory and illegal.

“The Karuk Tribe has as much right to buy advertising space on publicly owned buses as anyone else,” said Leaf Hillman, Vice Chairman of the Karuk Tribe. “Our ad simply promotes a website with information about Pacific Power’s Klamath dams and how they impact the river as well as power rates. Refusing to run this ad is discriminatory and illegal.”

I agree. Why is TriMet refusing to run the ad? Why are they refusing to allow the Karuk Tribe and FOR to get out their message about the necessity of removing four Klamath River dams?

"Experts have shown that removing those dams -- and replacing the electricity they produce with other renewable sources of power -- would actually be cheaper than PacifiCorp's plan to keep the dams and build fish ladders," according to Friends of the River. "So we thought by running this ad on Portland area buses, PacifiCorp customers would start to raise the issue with their utility."

The refusal of the public bus company to run the ad occurs within the context of increasing repression of freedom of speech across the country by the federal and state governments and regional government entities. It is deplorable that TriMet chose not to run the ad - and I urge environmental activists and free speech advocates to support the ACLU, Karuk Tribe and Friends of the River in their legal battle against TriMet's blatant attempt at censorship. The Tribe and FOR should be allowed to run their ad about the need for PacifiCorp ratepayers to support salmon restoration by pressuring the Warren Buffett-owned subsidiary to remove its four Klamath River dams.

Stand up for freedom of speech and dam removal. Go to http://www.salmonforsavings.com for more information.  

ACLU OF OREGON · KARUK TRIBE · FRIENDS OF THE RIVER

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Contacts:
David Fidanque, Executive Director, ACLU of Oregon
(541) 954-7731
S. Craig Tucker, Klamath Campaign Coordinator, Karuk Tribe of California
(530) 627-3446 Ext. 3027 (office) or (916) 207-8294 (cell)
Kelly Catlett, Hydropower Reform Policy Advocate, Friends of the River
(916) 442-3155 Ext. 223

ACLU Files Free Speech Lawsuit Against TriMet

FEBRUARY 20, 2008 – The ACLU of Oregon today filed a lawsuit against Tri-County Metropolitan Transportation District of Oregon (TriMet), alleging the public bus company has violated federal and state constitutional free speech protections in its rejection of an advertisement it deems “political.”

The lawsuit was filed this morning in Multnomah County Circuit Court, on behalf of the Karuk Tribe of California and Friends of the River Foundation, who had sought to place an ad on TriMet buses regarding the damage done to salmon runs by electricity-generating dams, owned by Portland-based Pacific Power, on the Klamath River . The ad depicts three salmon facing a wall of electrical sockets, along with the caption, “Salmon shouldn’t run up your electric bill. They should run up the Klamath River .” The ad then directs the public to a website – http://www.salmonforsavings.com – for more information. (A copy of the ad is attached.)

TriMet’s Advertising Standards Committee rejected the proposed ad on the grounds that it did not constitute an “advertisement” and that the public transit agency did not want its buses or property “to become a public forum for the dissemination, debate, and/or discussion of public issues.” The ACLU appealed the committee’s decision to TriMet’s general manager, who in a letter dated Jan. 18, 2008 , upheld the rejection.

The ACLU contends that both rejections represent an unlawful restriction on speech in violation of Article 1, section 8, of the Oregon Constitution and the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. In filing its Petition for Writ of Review, the ACLU is asking the court to review these administrative decisions and determine whether TriMet’s advertising policies are unconstitutional.

“TriMet’s policies discriminate on speech based on its content, and we believe that is unconstitutional,” said David Fidanque, Executive Director of the ACLU of Oregon. “A public agency should not place itself in the role of deeming some speech acceptable and some speech objectionable. TriMet’s job is to transport riders, not to override free speech protections.”

The Karuk Tribe and Friends of the River seek to restore healthy salmon populations to the Klamath River . Their objective is the removal of PacifiCorp’s lower four Klamath River dams, allowing salmon to access more than 300 miles of their historic habitat.

“The Karuk Tribe has as much right to buy advertising space on publicly owned buses as anyone else,” said Leaf Hillman, Vice Chairman of the Karuk Tribe. “Our ad simply promotes a website with information about Pacific Power’s Klamath dams and how they impact the river as well as power rates. Refusing to run this ad is discriminatory and illegal.”

The Karuk Tribe and Friends of the River cite economic studies by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission and the California Energy Commission that show removing the dams and purchasing renewable replacement energy would save Pacific Power ratepayers about $100 million.

“We are trying to get the word out to Pacific Power’s customers that dam removal could save them a significant amount of money,” said Kelly Catlett, Hydropower Reform Policy Advocate for Friends of the River. “It’s unfortunate TriMet thinks that is a message that needs to be censored.”

The writ demands that TriMet turn over to the court, within two weeks, its documentation of the refusal of the ad. A court hearing then would follow.

Thomas M. Christ of Cosgrave Vergeer Kester LLP is ACLU’s cooperating attorney on this case.

See http://www.salmonforsavings.com for more information.

S. Craig Tucker, Ph.D.
Klamath Campaign Coordinator
Karuk Tribe of California
office: 530-627-3446 x3027
cell: 916-207-8294
ctucker [at] karuk.us

http://www.karuk.us


From Friends of the River (http://www.friendsoftheriver.org):

This ad is too controversial?!

Not that bad, right? We're scratching our heads to figure out what the problem is with this ad and our message. But I guess we'll find out in court!

All we're trying to do is bring this message is to the people. Portland citizens who get their electricity from PacifiCorp should know that their utility could run up their electric bills by refusing to take down four dams on the Klamath River . Those dams do very little but block the passage for salmon and detroy the once-mighty river.

Experts have shown that removing those dams -- and replacing the electricity they produce with other renweable sources of power -- would actually be cheaper than PacifiCorp's plan to keep the dams and build fish ladders. So we thought by running this ad on Portland area buses, PacifiCorp customers would start to raise the issue with their utility.

Well, we didn't get that far. The Tri-County Metropolitan District of Oregon (TriMet), the company in charge of the Portland buses, deemed this ad too "political."

We could use your support. The Oregon ACLU filed the lawsuit on our behalf, and they think that the argument for upholding our right to free speech is a strong one. But this lawsuit means more time and energy is put onto work that we didn't expect. So we'd like to ask for your participation and your monetary support.

Participate: The Portland bus ads are a key part of our Klamath campaign. But there are other ways to get the word out. The best way is through word of mouth. Please pass this ad on to as many friends as you can. Because TriMet can't stop you from passing this message on. 

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
NOTE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, any copyrighted
material  herein is distributed without profit or payment to those who have
expressed  a  prior interest in receiving this information for non-profit
research and  educational purposes only. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml

Source:  http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2008/02/20/18480644.php