“Leaping Steelhead” Conservation Awards
for 2006
by Dan Bacher
Last year I instituted a new set of conservation awards, the
“Leaping Steelhead” awards, for those who have gone out of their
way to restore and enhance our fish populations in the face of
decades of state and federal government mismanagement of our
fisheries. Although the focus of these awards will be on river and
estuary restoration, we will include other areas of fishery
conservation. This column will be followed by the annual “Cold,
Dead Fish” awards for 2006.
2006 was a trying year for anglers, with anglers facing potential
closure of the entire ocean salmon season in California and Oregon
due to the decimation of Klamath River salmon stocks. Although a
coalition of conservation groups, Indian Tribes and fishing
organizations successfully pressured the Bush administration to
allow a severely reduced commercial salmon season and a relatively
status quo recreational salmon season, the hard work of removing the
Klamath River dams and restoring the river remains.
The conservation battles I covered focused around three major areas
(1) restoring the Klamath River and taking PacifiCorp’s dams down,
(2) fighting against state and federal attempts to increase water
exports from the Bay Delta estuary and (3) pressuring SMUD to go
back to negotiations with the agencies and NGO’s over relicensing
of the Upper American River Project.
We’re going to start with the biggest, most prestigious award
first – the “Leaping Steelhead” award. One thing I notice in
the many meetings I go to is that most of the folks are middle aged
and graying, so it’s great to see young people involved in fishery
conservation. I am giving this award to three young women, Regina
Chichizola, Erika Chase and Kayla Carpenter, for their outstanding
work on bringing public awareness to the battle to take down the
Klamath dams and restore water quality on the Klamath.
Regina Chichizola, the recently hired Klamath Riverkeeper, developed
increasing public awareness of the Klamath’s water quality
problems and mobilized folks for rallies and meetings regarding
restoring the river in 2006. She publishes a regular news update
that goes to a variety of media sources and activists and has been a
whirlwind of activity since taking over the Riverkeeper position
last year, organizing the “ground troops” for events like the
California Water Resources Control Board I attended in October.
While at Hoopa Valley High School, Kayla Carpenter, a Yurok tribal
member, and Erika Chase, a Hoopa tribal member, organized an annual
relay run starting in 2003 in response to the 2002 adult fish kill
on the Klamath. On Memorial Day weekend of 2006, the duo, friends
since fourth grade, and other organizers extended the run from its
original 41 miles to a 214 mile relay run to honor Klamath River
salmon from the mouth to Iron Gate Dam. The relay runners called for
increased water flows and the removal of the lower four Klamath
River Dams as steps necessary for restoring the salmon population.
“Since the fish kill, things have only gotten worse for our
salmon. That’s why this year we’re running all the way to Iron
Gate Dam. We want to highlight the fact that dam removal is part of
the solution,“ announced Carpenter before the run.
What distinguishes these three women is the initiative they have
taken to get the Klamath River Indian Tribes, recreational anglers,
commercial fishermen and conservation groups together. I hope that
more young folks in their teens and twenties follow their example!
Now for our other prestigious awards to those who did outstanding
work on behalf of our fisheries.
A special award, the “Advance Warning” award,
goes to Jim Martin, West Coast director of the Recreational Fishing
Alliance, who keeps on top of the Pacific Fishery Management Council
(PFMC) like no other guy in the industry, for alerting anglers in
the recreational fishing community about the potential closure of
the recreational ocean salmon seasons months before it happened.
Just as Martin forecasted, the DFG reported on the dire status of
the Klamath stocks at the Salmon Fishery Informational meeting in
Santa Rosa in February.
The grim news released at the DFG meeting was followed by a vote of
the PFMC, under direction from the White House, on March 10 to delay
the opening of recreational salmon season from Point Arena to Point
Sur set for April 1. Fortunately, the DFG responded by stating that
state waters, within 3 miles from shore, from Point Arena to Pigeon
Point would remain open until further notice.
Angered by the proposed closure by the Bush administration, an array
of recreational and commercial fishing organizations organized
rallies and packed PFMC meetings to draw attention to the dire need
to fix the water quality problems on the Klamath and bring down the
Klamath River dams owned by PacifiCorp.
The American Sportfishing Association (ASA) set up an easy-to-send
action alert on their website to send letters protesting the closure
and supporting the restoration of the Klamath, while the Coastside
Fishing Club and other organizations mobilized anglers to sign
letters and send thousands of letters through the ASA website. The
Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen's Associations (PCFFA) also
mobilized hundreds of commercial fishermen to sign its petitions.
For their successful letter writing campaign, Dick Pool of the ASA,
Chris Hall, president, and Bob Franko, founder of the Coastside
Fishing Club, receive the “Letters to Washington” awards.
During this time, Zeke Grader, executive director of the PCFFA,
made one of the most hilarious statements of the year to the press.
“Closing salmon fishing to put fish back into the Klamath River
without fixing the river’s water problems is like throwing virgins
into a volcano. Neither action will save us,” said the
always-quotable Grader, who receives the “Zany Zinger” of the
year award.
Likewise, Troy Fletcher, a Yurok tribal member and natural resources
consultant for the tribe, gets the “Speak Sense to
Nonsense” award for his call to action at the PFMC meeting in
Sacramento in April, reiterated at a rally in San Francisco on April
24 announcing Mike Thompson’s salmon fishing industry disaster
relief bill. “What we need is not another Blue Ribbon Panel,
but a Blue Collar Panel with the guys who get their hands wet,”
said Fletcher.
Meanwhile, a coalition of Indian Tribes, recreational anglers and
commercial fishermen spent the year battling for the removal of the
Klamath River dams by packing hearings and sending out action alert
after action alert and press release after press release calling on
Pacific Power, now under the ownership of a Warren Buffet
subsidiary, to pull down the Klamath Dams. For their
leadership roles, Klamath campaign coordinator Craig Tucker,
cultural biologist Ron Reed and Vice-Chairman Leaf Hillman of the
Karuk Tribe and Mike Hudson, president of the Small Boat Commercial
Salmon Fishermen’s Association, receive the “Take Down the
Dams” awards for the monumental efforts they made on this front.
While anglers battled to save the salmon season and restore the
Klamath, the Delta food chain continued to decline as state and
federal scientists released data documenting how the Delta smelt
population and juvenile striped bass index collapsed to the lowest
levels ever recorded. Anglers, duck hunters and local residents
upset with state and federal plans to export water through the South
Delta vented their fury during a public hearing regarding the South
Delta Improvements Program (SDIP) in Stockton on January 26. Again
on February 28, a diverse array of fishing and environmental groups
appeared at Rep. Richard Pombo’s Delta hearing.
In June, a coalition of anglers, farmworkers and environmental
justice advocates organized an excellent turnout at the Central
Valley Regional Water Control Board meeting in Sacramento to subject
agribusiness to the same general discharge permit that others have
to abide by. Unfortunately, the Central Valley Regional Water
Quality Control Board voted on June 22 to extend waivers for
discharges from irrigated farmland for five years.
For organizing such a diverse group of people with superb testimony
and presentations, Carrie McNeil, the Deltakeeper, Bill Jennings,
executive director of the California Sportfishing Protection
Alliance, Susana de Anda of La Association de Gente Unida por el
Agua, Laurel Firestone of the Center for Race, Poverty and the
Environment, and Bob Strickland, president of United Anglers of
California, receive the “Stop the Ag Pollution” award.
Throughout the year, one guy who showed up at virtually every
hearing or meeting regarding the Delta was Gary Adams, president of
the California Striped Bass Association (CSBA), along with John
Banks and other members of the group. For their dedication to
fighting the exporters and polluters, Adams and the CSBA win the
“Delta Ironmen” award.
Another person who is on top of every development in the Delta is
Mindy McIntire, water program manager of the Planning and
Conservation League. It was through her diligence that she broadcast
another threat to our fisheries, the Delta Intertie Project that
would allow the state and federal projects to export more water. For
her excellent work, she receives the “Delta Sleuth” award.
David Nesmith, Environmental Water Caucus facilitator, serves an
invaluable role linking a wide-ranging and often contentious
coalition of environmental and fishing groups over a variety of
Central Valley and Bay-Delta Estuary issues. For his dedication and
great work, he is given the “Fish Networker of 2006” award.
Probably the most surprisingly hard battle of 2006
was the struggle by fishing groups, environmental activists, and
white water recreational boaters to pressure the Sacramento
Municipal Utility District (SMUD) to go back to the bargaining table
with the state and federal government agencies. Jim Shetler, head of
the negotiating team of the Sacramento Municipal Utility District (SMUD),
on November 16 finally announced a historic "agreement in
principle" between federal and state agencies, NGOs and the
public utility over the terms and conditions of its 50-year license
for its Upper American River.
Although there are plenty of folks who helped out, five dedicated
people who spent hundreds and hundreds of hours in the negotiations
were Ron Stork, senior policy analyst for Friends of the River,
Bill Center of the American River Recreation, Association,
Chris Schutes of the California Sportfishing Protection Alliance,
Nate Rangel, president of California Outdoors, and Hilde Schweitzer.
For their perseverance, they are bestowed the “Wild
Rainbow Trout" awards.
For their constant action alerts and emails, Teresa (Tree) Simsiman,
recreational white water boater, and Soren Jesperson, campaigns
organizer with Friends of the River, win the “Victory in the
Sierra” plaques. Likewise, Bill Templin, watershed coordinator of
the North Fork American River Watershed, gets the “Preserve the
American” award for his superb work in organizing folks to
preserve and restore the Upper American.