Even
the driest of winters would not test the "adequacy" of the
Northwest's supply of electricity despite the region's heavy reliance
on hydro power, according to recent analysis produced by the Northwest
Power and Conservation Council's Power Division staff.
"It
almost really doesn't matter," senior system analyst John Fazio
told the Council Wednesday. Since 1999 when the region had a 4,000
average megawatt deficit, the region has lost about 10 percent of its
demand and gained about 15 percent in generation.
The
result is about a 6,400 average megawatt swing to a 2,400 surplus
supply. By way of comparison, the surplus is about twice as much
electricity as the city of Seattle
consumes in a year.
The
current energy adequacy standard adopted last year by the Council
requires the region to maintain at least a balance between resources
and loads on an annual basis. The standard includes a 1,500 megawatt
planning adjustment. So the new adequacy analysis shows the region
with a 3,900 average megawatt surplus in relation to the standards.
The
NPCC staff power outlook is based on critical hydro conditions, the
driest winter on record -- 1936-37. Most of the moisture that pours
through hydroelectric dams over the course of the year comes from
snowpack that builds over the winter.
At
this point in time, hydro provides about 75 percent of the electricity
consumed in the region on average with gas fired plants and other
sources providing the remainder. Even in a critical water year hydro
could still provide slightly more than half of the region's power.
"We
could keep the lights on but it would cost more," Fazio of the
switch to other resources.
He
stressed that the analysis is of power supply only. It doesn't take
into account potential problems transmitting that power to all the
corners of the region, or unexpected instances of hydropower sources
going offline for mechanical failures or other reasons.
"The
bottom line is that we don't expect a problem," Fazio told the
Council.
Power
demand decreased because some large industries, particularly aluminum
plants, have reduced production. Also, the regional economy still has
not fully recovered from the energy crisis of 2000 and 2001, when a
short supply -- in part caused by a drought in the
hydropower-dominated Northwest -- combined with regulatory problems in
California to drive up prices significantly, according to a Council
press release.
According
to the Council's analysis, the power supply now is 41 percent above
average during the winter demand period, and 28 percent above average
summer demand.
With
the winter snow collection period past the halfway mark, the Northwest
River Forecast predicts spring-summer runoff will be near average.
That means the supply of hydroelectricity should be normal through the
spring and summer months, according to Council analysis.
The
Council based its analysis on a forecast of the January-July Columbia
River runoff volume issued Jan. 8. The forecast, based on measurements
of snowpack and assuming normal precipitation through the end of July,
predicts a runoff volume during the seven-month period that totals 105
million acre-feet at The Dalles Dam, which is 98 percent of the
30-year historical average. The volume at the lower
Columbia
dam represents runoff from a large share of the
Columbia
Basin
.
The
forecasted runoff volume in other areas of the basin are both lower --
82 percent of average at Idaho Power Company's Brownlee Dam on the
Snake River, for example -- and higher -- 126 percent of normal for
the Yakima River, and 100 percent of normal at Grand Coulee Dam. The
forecast is for 94 percent of normal runoff at the lower
Snake River
's Lower Granite Dam. Tributaries such as the
Clearwater
, Salmon, Imnaha and Grand Ronde flow into the Snake between
Hells Canyon
and Lower Granite.
"The
regional surplus of electricity, combined with the predicted average
runoff, is good news for Northwest electricity consumers because it
means high prices are unlikely," Council Chairman Tom Karier of
Spokane
said.
An
average runoff year means that meeting flow targets desired for salmon
and steelhead migrations are dicey.
Based
on average flows over the years, a slightly subpar water year gives
"probably a 50-50 chance that we are going to meet that target in
the spring" at Lower Granite on the lower Snake River and McNary
on the
Columbia
, Fazio said. With average flows, summer targets are rarely met.
"We
just don't meet it that often with the reservoirs we've got,"
Fazio said. Those reservoirs are only capable of storing at any given
time about 15 percent of the annual runoff
The
supply adequacy analysis assumes that power generated by independent
power producers, about 2,700 megawatts, would be available in the
Northwest. Even if that power were sold outside the Northwest,
however, the surplus still be would on the order of 1,200 megawatts,
according to the Council.
A
nearly normal forecasted runoff means that hydropower dams in the
Columbia
River Basin
will produce nearly 4,000 megawatts more electricity than would be
produced under critical water conditions.
The
supply and price of electricity should remain at average levels
through the spring and summer even if the U.S. District Court in
Portland
orders an increase in water spills at Snake and
Columbia river
dams to aid passage of juvenile salmon and steelhead, according to the
Council. The region's electricity surplus is large enough that an
increase in spills, which would reduce hydropower generation, would
not eliminate the surplus.