Become a friend of

   the Klamath Bucket  

            Brigade

   Send Donations Here

     All donations are tax  

             deductible

 

 

 This Website is Dedicated to

 Alvin Alexander Cheyne

January 10, 1921 - June 17, 2005

 

 

 

      

Who gets the water?


Now when cities seek to tap into lakes, rivers or streams, fish may have something to say about it


June 24, 2007

Water. We use about 408 billion gallons every day in the United States, according to the U.S. Geological Survey. That’s over 1,000 gallons a day for every citizen. We use it to make electricity, to irrigate crops, we bathe in it and use it to make lemonade and beer.

In 2005, the Oregon legislature decided if there was one creature by which to measure the health of our rivers and lakes, it was a fish. Since then, fish such as steelhead, chinook, chub and lamprey must be considered when people get permission from the state to use water.

There are about 100 municipalities, including Corvallis, Salem and Adair Village, whose water use permits are up for extension. Permits are granted for limited amounts of water and for limited spans of time, and periodically they must be reviewed by the Oregon Water Resources Department.

Now fish that are listed as “sensitive,” “threatened” or “endangered” by either the state or the federal government must be taken into account in approving those water permits. The Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife is charged with making sure listed fish “persist,” or survive.

It’s an unprecedented situation in Oregon, and only two of the cities or water districts applying for extensions to their permits are moving ahead to see if they are approved. All others have placed their applications on hold, waiting to see what happens.

The “persistence of fish” is not a legal term, so ODFW, the League of Oregon Cities and environmental groups such as Water Watch of Oregon have all contributed their opinions about what it should mean. Rick Kepler at ODFW said the listed fish are already in jeopardy. So for them to survive over a period of years, their environment must show some improvement, not just maintain the status quo.

Willie Tiffany, from LOC, said that definition puts an undue burden on cities who need to grow and serve their residents.

“(Municipalities) withdrawing water, if there is any impact, you’d have to put water back,” Tiffany said, if they use the ODFW definition. “Bucket for bucket.“

That’s just not possible for cities that are expanding.

The two applicants moving ahead are the Tualatin Valley Water District and a group of eight permit-holders on the Clackamas River. The TVWD needs water and needs it now, so its permit extension became a test case to see how the competing interests would sort themselves out and still comply with the law. TVWD is on the brink of getting approval.

“We’ll be getting all of the signatures to approve the agreement, hopefully within a couple of days,” Dwight French, an administrator at Water Resources Department, said Friday.

That will mean TVWD can move ahead with plans to use an additional 130 million gallons of water per day. The process hasn’t been smooth sailing. After months of negotiation, TVWD has agreed to adjust its withdrawal of water from the Willamette according to a designated level of flow that fish require to spawn at designated times of the year. If the flow goes down below a certain level, then TVWD has to decrease the amount of water it uses.

“If the river is down by 8 percent,” said Debbie Colbert of Water Resources, “then the water district will have to decrease its usage by 8 percent.“

There is a ceiling of 20 percent. Measurements of flow will be taken monthly at Salem, according to Colbert. She said TVWD asked to be able to manage their own usage rather than have the state do it. They believe if they know the parameters, they can adjust to meet them.

That’s all very well for TVWD. They have an alternate water source from the city of Portland if the Willamette gets low. But cities like Corvallis don’t have the same back-up supply.

“We don’t, and that was one of my concerns,” said Tom Penpraze, utilities division manager for Corvallis. “We do have the Rock Creek water supply, but when we need it the most, in the summer, it dries up.“

Corvallis wants to be able to use up to 31.5 million more gallons per day than the 26.7 million it currently uses. Penpraze has asked the state to extend the permit to the year 2075. If Corvallis is forced to reduce water withdrawals because of low flow in the Willamette, the city could be in a bind and water rationing could be the result sometime in the future. But Corvallis is fine for now.

So Penpraze watches and waits to see what happens in the TVWD case.

But the situation in Adair Village, which also draws its water from the Willamette, is more urgent. Adair’s water treatment plant and pipes were built during World War II when the city was Camp Adair. Tests have shown that as much as 45 percent of the treated water from their plant is not making it to consumers because of leaks. A recent study by a firm of consulting engineers estimates it will cost Adair $11 million to build a new plant to meet existing need.

And Adair is planning to grow. It recently voted to extend its urban growth boundary adding as many as 600 new homes and has been taking steps to clean up the Boise-Cascade industrial property for future use. Both of those projects would use more water than is now available with the aging system.

One solution is to follow the model of the water districts on the Clackamas River. There, eight municipalities and districts with permits have gotten together to create a plan on a basin-wide scale, according to Colbert. Those regional solutions to water management may be the wave of the future.

Adair now uses about 1.9 million gallons of water a day. It has a permit, under review by Water Resources, to allow it to use almost 53 million gallons, much more than its projected need.

“We have an opportunity to become a regional water supplier,” said Adair Mayor Bill Currier.

Both Albany and Corvallis have expressed interest in collaborating with Adair to develop its permit. Albany has been active in that effort, particularly to provide water for North Albany.

And Adair needs money to build a new plant. With a population of about 920, the city can’t come up with $11 million on its own.

“Most likely we would partner with a neighbor such as the City of Albany to fund a new facility,” Currier said. And soon. “Hopefully we can make some kind of agreement within 60 days.”

An additional requirement for permit extensions is for cities to develop and present water conservation plans. Penpraze said Corvallis is ahead of the game there, because the city has been developing conservation plans for years even though they were not required by the state.

Adair has kicked into high gear to develop and plan, with meetings set for July to consult with engineers and possible partners.

In the meantime, all eyes are on the Willamette River and the Tualatin Valley Water District. And on the fish.

Gwyneth Gibby can be reached at 758-9548 or
gwyneth.gibby@lee.net.

 
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
NOTE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, any copyrighted
material  herein is distributed without profit or payment to those who have
expressed  a  prior interest in receiving this information for non-profit
research and  educational purposes only. For more information go to:http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml