Adjusting the ESA
Groups back species act reformation
Some Klamath County political groups
say the Endangered Species Act is being used to push environmental
agendas and cripple economic growth.
The Klamath County Republican
Central Committee is among local organizations
pushing to change the federal act
designed to protect habitats of animals and plants. In March, the
committee formally passed a resolution in favor of modifying the ESA.
Jeff Woodwick, the committee’s
chairman, said the ESA has had an adverse impact on the Klamath Basin
economy, choking off economic opportunities in sectors like timber
production and agriculture.
“We felt strongly that this is
something that has to be done
for the benefit of our economy,” Woodwick said.
Exactly what that modification might
look like isn’t clear, but Woodwick said it would likely include taking
regional and economic considerations into account when implementing ESA
provisions to make sure rural communities aren’t disproportionately
impacted.
“I would say (the ESA) has affected
us more than other areas of the country, because we’re a rural, resource
communit y,” Woodwick said.
Among groups endorsing ESA
modification is the Klamath County Patriots Tea Party organization.
Spokesman Jack Charlton called the
ESA “well intended in its beginning.” But he added “there are portions
of it that are very intrusive to what the
Pacific Northwest needs to maintain
its income viability.”
Charlton pointed to the situation
with the shortnose sucker and spotted owl, which went on the endangered
species list in 1988 and 1990, respectively. They’ve contributed to
declining timber production and water shortages for irrigators in the
Klamath Basin, Charlton said, resulting in massive job and productivity
losses.
“I don’t think anybody that is of
sane and sound mind wants to hurt our ecosystem,” he said. “But there’s
a point where you get ludicrous about it.”
Woodwick said he’s taken the g roups’
concerns to the office of U.S. Congressman Greg Walden, R-Ore. Walden
spokesman Andrew Whelan said Walden shares
their concerns.
“Rep. Walden has long been a
supporter of reforming and modernizing the ESA,” Whelan said. “He
certainly supports removing barriers to job creation in natural
resources.”
Woodwick said even some members of
the local Democratic Party have been willing to listen to reform
efforts.
But Liz Schmitt, treasurer for the
Klamath County Democrats, said “there’s a big difference between
listening and agreeing.”
The issues related to the ESA “are
not simple problems, they’re very complicated and they have domino
effects,” Schmitt said, adding removing protections on species like
spotted owls or suckers could have widespread ecological impacts.