September 20, 2005
Klamath
Falls Herald and News
By DYLAN DARLING
U.S. Rep. Greg Walden appears at a rally Monday for a bill to revamp the 32-year old Endangered Species Act. The rally was held on the steps of the Klamath County Government Center.
A new bill that would change the Endangered
Species Act would prevent crises like the one that rocked the Klamath Basin in
summer of 2001, says one of the lawmakers who crafted it.
U.S. Rep. Greg Walden came to Klamath Falls Monday afternoon for a rally in
support of the bill. Earlier in the day, he and other sponsors unveiled it in
Sacramento.
Walden said the law "isn't working to recover
species."
Changes proposed in the "Threatened and Endangered Species Recovery Act
of 2005" include:
Kristen Boyles, a Seattle attorney for Earthjustice, a non-profit law firm that represents environmental interests, argues that the act has been doing what it was intended to do, keep species from going extinct.
"They are still here, they are still with us," Boyles said.
She said it took hundred of years to get species into trouble and the
process of recovering them could also be lengthy.
"None of these are going to be overnight solutions."
The most controversial change proposed in the bill
would make the government pay "fair market" price for property
needed in a project to benefit ESA protected species.
Former State Sen. Steve Harper introduced Walden at a Klamath Falls rally
and charged that environmental groups are able to "steal" private
property by forcing restoration projects on it, but not paying for it.
The change would make the taking of such land similar to when the
government takes private land for a freeway, Walden said. Now people will be
compensated for their land.
Boyles said the bill's language is vague and people couldn't simply say they
might be harmed by an Endangered Species Act project and then they would get
a payment from the government.
"It's clearly made to bankrupt the
system," she said.
The money used to buy property would take away from the budget for projects,
she said.
The 72-page bill, House Bill 3824, combines crusades
by more than a dozen lawmakers to change the ESA, such as U.S. Reps Richard
Pombo, a California Republican, and Dennis Cardoza, a California Democrat.
'We specifically came out to California and Oregon because this is where the
problems are," Walden said.
Citing 2001, Walden said, "The Klamath Basin is ground zero in the
effort to reform the ESA."
If the changes proposed in the bill had been in place in 2001, "I doubt
the water would have been turned off here," Walden said.
He outlined the bill atop the steps of the Klamath County Government Center
Monday afternoon.
At the announcement, Walden was surrounded by people and things telling of
the 2001 water issue.
In the crowd of about 50 were farmers and ranchers, as well as county and
city leaders.
Behind him was a shinny green tractor holding a sign that said "Amend
the ESA," which had been used at the 2001 Bucket Brigade protest that
garnered national attention. In front of him was a giant metal bucket
symbolic of the event.
In all, six Democrats and eight Republicans - from Arkansas, Mississippi,
Missouri, Nevada, Oregon, South Carolina, Washington and Wyoming - signed as
co-sponsors of the bill, which was spearheaded by Pombo.
The bill may succeed where others have failed because it is bipartisan, its
writers said.
Pombo's U.S. House Resources Committee passed two bills last year to amend
the ESA but neither got a vote on the House floor. Earlier attempts to amend
the law also went nowhere, including a 1997 effort that cleared a Senate
committee.
A congressional hearing concerning the bill is set for Wednesday in
Washington, D.C.
-The Associated Press contributed to this story
On the Net:
http://resourcescommittee.house.gov/
Source: http://www.heraldandnews.com/articles/2005/09/20/news/top_stories/topspecies.txt