New York TimesSAN
FRANCISCO — The federal
Fish and Wildlife Service
this week underscored the imminent threat of extinction
facing the delta smelt, a two-inch-long fish native to the
Sacramento River delta, when it announced it was considering
whether to declare the fish endangered.
California
is in a quandary because two-thirds of its residents get
water through the pumps that have been killing large numbers
of smelt. This year, for the first time, a federal judge’s
order kept state and federal water agencies from collecting
their usual part of the river water flowing from melting
snow from the Sierra Nevada. Water users from the Bay Area
to San Diego were affected by the resulting reductions of 20
percent to 30 percent.
This is taking place after a spring that
has been one of the driest on record, leaving even less
water for the fiercely competitive interests fighting for a
share of a dear commodity.
“A comprehensive approach to conserving
this fish is going to require onerous restrictions in
pumping,” said Timothy Quinn, director of the Association of
California Water Agencies.
The distribution of water used to mean
“that you killed fish,” Mr. Quinn said, adding, “Now the
fish have very strong legal protection, to the point where
they are becoming a dominant policy consideration. To
protect the fish means losing massive amounts of the water
supply.”
A spokesman for the Fish and Wildlife
Service in Sacramento, said smelt populations this year were
92 percent smaller than a decade ago. Should the agency
decide to change the smelt’s status to endangered from
threatened, he said, the protections would be largely the
same.
Michael Boccadoro, a spokesman for the
Coalition for a Sustainable Delta, a group representing
major water users, said that “from an operational
perspective,” a status change for the smelt would “make
little difference because threatened and endangered species
have the same protection.”
Tina Swanson, executive director of the
Bay Institute, a conservation organization, said the
potential change in the fish’s status “should send up an
urgency flag” for regulators that they need to resolve the
complex issues involved in maintaining and transporting the
state’s water supplies.