Columbia River Dams: Beyond breaching
P-I EDITORIAL BOARD
November 26, 2006
A new report shows big economic benefits from
tearing down the four worst offenders among the Columbia River Basin's
more than 200 dams. A more encouraging development is the eagerness of
environmental, energy and fishing groups to talk with those who feel
threatened by dam removal.
There's nothing earthshaking in the idea that
removing four Lower Snake Rivers would bring greater benefits for
fish, the environment and tourism than the costs. The new Revenue
Stream report compiles previous estimates to conclude the benefits
would nearly double the costs, at minimum.
There are entrenched feelings, however. Sen. Larry
Craig, R-Idaho, would like to block federal spending to comply with a
valid court order for new consideration of the dams' effects on salmon
and steelhead. It's an offensive idea springing from repeated court
decisions on the need to protect fish.
Environmentalists can keep winning in court. But
solutions will come from talking. Reaching out to inland communities
with sound numbers and open minds is the key to resolving questions
about irrigation, shipping and other issues.