One hasn't learned to expect the federal
government to stick to its guns on environmental issues -- in recent
years, anyway. So we were surprised and pleased to see that the U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service
were not only firm on Tuesday, but showed some sharp teeth, too.
In pushing Klamath River hydropower dam owner
Pacificorp to install ladders for salmon and other fish if it wants
its license renewed, the agencies also ripped the company for its
lame proposal to trap fish and truck them around the dams instead.
The federal government's insistence could make it
more likely that there may be a settlement with Pacificorp leading
to the tearing out one or more of the four Klamath dams in question.
Ladders will cost electric ratepayers more,
because the cost of installing them -- up to $300 million -- could
be passed along. A better deal the long run, say state and federal
agencies, conservation groups and Indian tribes, would be to take
down the dams and build modern power plants instead.
That outcome will continue to be on the table in
ongoing settlement talks. We hope Pacificorp joins the rest of us on
the North Coast in agreeing that it would be the best outcome for
everyone -- particularly the fish.