So much for energy independence.
The Washington Post downplayed the potential loss of four Western
hydroelectric dams that might be destroyed to make life easier … for
salmon.
According to the
January 31 article by the Post’s Blaine
Harden, the destruction of the dams “has extraordinary potential to
rebound as a major salmon resource, according to fish biologists and
regional officials.”
It wasn’t until the seventh paragraph that Harden even
mentioned the four dams provide power for 70,000 people near the
Klamath, “which straddles the Oregon-California border.” There was
no clear answer where the substitute power would be obtained.
According to the article, the federal government ruled that the
dam owners must spend $300 million to modify them to accommodate the
needs of salmon. That is $101 million more than it would cost to tear
down the four dams.
Harden explained the real motivation behind the dam destruction
– problems that include “angry irrigators, litigious
environmentalists and Indian tribes whose diet and culture have been
substantially damaged by the disappearance of salmon.”
Dave Kvamme, a spokesman for dam owners PacifiCorp, was the only
one to point out the added strain on energy capacity, “adding that his
company urgently needs to create more electricity generation and regards
the dams as ‘an extremely valuable resource.’”
This certainly wasn’t the first time environmentalists have
been able to tear down existing energy capacity. According to the story,
“In three other license-renewal cases, PacifiCorp has agreed to remove
dams from Western rivers.” While it doesn’t include totals, the Clearinghouse
for Dam Removal Information lists projects in
process from
Maine
to
California
.
Ironically, the Post took an entirely different position just
five days earlier on January 26. In an editorial, the paper criticized
the president’s energy plan because he “missed
opportunities to improve energy security and to combat climate
change.” Presumably, hydroelectric power would meet both of those
goals.
A January
24 Business & Media Institute story
described the broadcast media fascination with energy independence. “Gas
prices on the rise again. Many Americans ‘running on empty.’
There’s a lot more talk about energy independence,” a report from
CBS’s Harry Smith on the June 29, 2006, “Early Show.”